View Puzzle

Solution: The Bakery

Answer: LOAF-BEARING

Author: Pichusuperlover

Devs: Jenna Himawan, Shuxin Zhan

We are presented with a collection of clues, solving them leaves us with an alphabetical list of answers

German for "to flash"Blitzen
DejectedBlue
RentedBorrowed
Astronomical object sometimes said to foretell doomComet
Civil war losersConfederate States (Specific wording unimportant)
Hockey's SidneyCrosby
Venus' SonCupid
Ballerina, for oneDancer
Usain bolt, for exampleDasher
Cannibal partyDonner
It's sometimes called The HexagonFrance
Car juiceGas
Convertible to cash, in economicsLiquid
Home of the Maya and the AztecsMexico
Inventor of an equilibrium in game theoryNash
Cutting edgeNew
AncientOld
One who strutsPrancer
Battle of the Alamo's loserRepublic of Texas (Not to be confused with the state of Texas)
Well-foundedSolid
Land of the Fighting BullSpain
Frames of a movieStills
Third-most populous countryUnited States (Specific wording unimportant)
Jenny RyanVixen
Each of the answers is associated with a set with an additional member
SetAbove AnswersAdditional member
Crosby, Stills & NashCrosby, Stills, NashYoung
Santa's reindeerDasher, Dancer, Prancer, Vixen, Comet, Cupid, Donner, BlitzenRudolph
Six flags over texasSpain, France, Mexico, Republic of Texas, United States, Confederate StatesRepublic of the Rio Grande
"Something old" rhymeOld, New, Borrowed, BlueSixpence
States of matterSolid, Liquid, GasPlasma
Putting these into the enumeration below and indexing by the numbers gives LOAF BEARING, which is the answer to this puzzle

Authors' Notes

When playing Binding of Isaac, I always found it funny that there were five four horsemen, I eventually realized it would make for a good puzzle premise and started noting down whenever I found sets that had an extra member, and that's how this puzzle came to be. The four horsemen didn't make the cut due to eventually discarding sets with a disagreed upon member rather than an extra member.